911 calls

The Ohio Supreme Court ruled last week that a prosecutor must pay attorney fees to The Cincinnati Enquirer for withholding 911 recordings, that newspaper's Kevin Grasha reports. The prosecutor did not have legal authority to withhold the recordings from a murder case, the court ruled, and must pay attorney fees to the newspaper.

The Connecticut General Assembly is considering a bill called the "look, listen but don't copy law," which would allow public access to homicide photos and 911 tapes to review them but not necessarily to get copies of them, the Connecticut Post reports. Family members of crime victims could cite an unwarranted invasion on their public privacy to block release of the records, then putting the onus on the public to show that there actually is no invasion, the Post reports.

After a nearly year-long open-records fight, a prosecutor relented on his opposition to the Associated Press's request to get copies of the 911 calls made as Adam Lanza shot schoolchildren and school professionals within 11 minutes of entering Sandy Hook Elementary School. The calls were released today, according to the AP. 

Teresa Rousseau, whose daughter Lauren was among the six educators killed and an editor at the Danbury News-Times, said "there was no need to play the tapes on the radio or television," the AP said. '"I think there's a big difference between secrecy and privacy," she said. "We have these laws so government isn't secret, not so we're invading victims' privacy,'" the AP also reported.

The Associated Press reports that prosecutor State's Attorney Stephen Sedensky III announced today he will no longer fight against the disclosure of 911 calls made as Adam Lanza shot schoolchildren and school officials at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Connecticut. Last week, Sedensky was ordered by a trial judge to release the 911 calls to the Associated Press. The AP says it wants to review the recordings, in part, to scrutinize the law enforcement response to the mass shooting.

The Connecticut Mirror reports that Superior Court Judge Eliot D. Prescott ordered the release of 911 calls made after Adam Lanza opened fire at the Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Conn., unless he is overturned on appeal.

'"Delaying the release of the audio recordings, particularly where the legal justification to keep them confidential is lacking, only serves to fuel speculation about and undermines confidence in our law enforcement officials,'" The Connecticut Mirror reported the judge opining.

The judge rejected all of the prosecution's argument to keep the 911 calls out of the public, including that releasing the calls would "have a chilling effect on those who might need to call 911," The Connecticut Mirror further reported.

The Associated Press is seeking the 911 calls.

The Associated Press reports that "a Connecticut judge said Friday that he wants to hear the 911 recordings from the Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting before ruling whether they can be released to the media."The judge set a Nov. 25 hearing on whether the recordings can be sealed so he access them, the AP also reports.

In the wake of the Sandy Hook school shootings, Connecticut has been having a huge debate on where to draw the line between public access to law enforcement records like 911 calls and protecting victims' families from further trauma and further invasions of their privacy. During testimony before a legislative task force, the spouse of one of the adults killed in the shooting suggested a compromise, according to the Hartford Courant: "Bill Sherlach, whose wife Mary was among the six adults and 20 children shot to death on Dec. 14, told members of the Task Force on Victim Privacy and the Public's Right to Know that he's willing to support a compromise: the release of a written account of the 911 calls made that day, as long as the audio is not made public. 'Transcripts can rely all the information that the public wants without having to hear the sounds of a slaughter in the background,'' he said."

There is a current debate in Connecticut on where to draw the line on access t0 law enforcement records like 911 tapes and crime-scene photos and the public's right to know in the wake of the shootings at Sandy Hook Elementary School. An attorney for most of the families of the Sandy Hook victims testified at a legislative task force that they do not want public disclosure of the 911 calls made because of the shooting, The Norwich Bulletin reports. While attorney Morgan Rueckert acknowledged the argument that the media has standards and does not always use the information accessed through right-t0-know requests, '"the reality is, every person now with a computer is an editor, a journalist and a publisher. The law needs to change to keep up and to stay in line with our peers."'

AP Editor William J. Kole writes that reason that his news organization requested the tapes of 911 calls made about the school shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Conn., is because it would be in the public interest to examine "the law enforcement response to one of the worst school shootings in U.S. history." But, while Kole said a prosecutor's refusal to release the records breaks the law, he also points out that the AP may not use the 911 calls: "It’s journalism’s dirty little secret: Just because we have information doesn’t necessarily mean we’re going to use it."

Connecticut is only one of nine states restricting the public disclosure of crime scene photos, Connecticut News Junkie reports on a survey conducted by the Connecticut Office of Legislative Research. Connecticut also is only one of 11 states restricting the public disclosure of 911 calls.

"Over the past few weeks the legislature’s research staff has been compiling reports for a task force convened by lawmakers to weigh the privacy of crime victims against the public’s right to know under the state’s Freedom of Information Act," Conneticut News Junkie reports. "The panel was created by a law that carved out new disclosure restrictions on the release of some law enforcement records pertaining to homicide victims and victims who are children" in the wake of the Sandy Hook school shootings.